Critiqing two of my peers Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words

Critiqing two of my peers - Essay Example ments because of the evidence presented, such as the statistics on accidents concerning underage drinking, and the fact that children’s brains are developing and they should not be stunted with alcohol. Its weakest argument is the one arguing for alcohol-related illness it is true that drinking at a young age can lead to cirrhosis, but it is not something particular to the age group being analyzed in this essay. All alcohol drinkers can develop these diseases, so saying this is not something that is directly relevant to the claims. The essay does not mention a counterargument. A counterargument that I would suggest is: â€Å"Opponents of setting the drinking age limit at 21 will stress that the age 18 is already a mature age for adolescents, so they should be given the freedom to drink what they want.† A response to this is providing evidence that people at the age of 18, who drink and drive, meet more accidents than people at 21, who drink and drive. Does the author use signal phrases to introduce quotes? (Signal phrases are discussed in more detail in section 10g of The New Century Handbook. ) If so, provide an example. If not, suggest the correct way to do this. Yes, the author uses signal phrases to introduce statistics, for example: â€Å"According to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention more than 189,000 children under the age of 21 are admitted to the emergency room annually because of alcohol.† He did not use direct quotations though. If he did, he can write one sentence this way: â€Å"Direnfeld (2012) describes a few different diseases that are related to alcohol, such as cirrhosis of the liver.† The quotations followed proper in-text citations, although the page or paragraph number is missing. For instance, this has no paragraph number: : â€Å"According to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention more than 189,000 children under the age of 21 are admitted to the emergency room annually because of alcohol.† The paragraph number is 1,